Exclusive interview

Billy Steinberg

The lyricist of “Like a Virgin” on a song that began as a ballad, a demo Madonna followed almost exactly, and why nobody else could have sung it.

By DrownedMadonna · 2005 · 12 min read

In short

  1. 01

    It began as a ballad

    Tom Kelly first set the lyric as a ballad. At the chorus it “sounded ridiculous”, and the bass line and the falsetto followed.

  2. 02

    Madonna followed the demo

    Steinberg says her record is “almost exactly like our original demo”. Nile Rodgers’ main contribution was the live bass and drums.

  3. 03

    It was not written for her

    Michael Ostin of Warner Bros. heard the demo and suggested Madonna, before “Borderline” and “Lucky Star” were hits.

Billy Steinberg wrote the words of “Like a Virgin” in 1983; Tom Kelly wrote the music. Together they also wrote “True Colors”, which Cyndi Lauper recorded.

This interview was conducted by email and first published on DrownedMadonna in 2005. The questions have been rewritten and the text edited for clarity. The answers are Billy Steinberg’s own words.

Where did you grow up and study?

I grew up in Palm Springs, California. I was a Literature major at Bard College in upstate New York.

What is your background?

My father was a farmer, growing table grapes in the Coachella Valley in Southern California.

What were your first influences and interests?

As a child, I was particularly passionate about two things: Baseball and Music. My favorite recording artists were Ricky Nelson (“Poor Little Fool”) and The Everly Brothers (“All I Have to Do Is Dream”). I had a treasured collection of 45’s (singles).

What about your first compositions?

In the late 1960’s, the first songs I wrote were folk songs, inspired by Bob Dylan, Donovan and others. The first song of mine to be recorded was “How Do I Make You” by Linda Ronstadt in 1980.

You have written many memorable songs over the past two decades with your friend Tom Kelly, including five No. 1 Billboard pop hits. Two of your greatest are Cyndi Lauper’s “True Colors” and, above all, Madonna’s “Like a Virgin”. When did you meet Tom, and when did you start writing together?

I met Tom Kelly in 1981 at a party at record producer Keith Olsen’s home in L.A. We wrote our first songs together shortly thereafter.

Do you still remember when you started writing “Like a Virgin”?

I wrote the lyric to “Like a Virgin” while sitting in my pickup truck in my family’s vineyard in Coachella, California.

How was it originally conceived? Was it an uptempo song from the very start?

“Like a Virgin” was written in 1983. The lyrics were written before the music. Because the first verse lyric starts out on a serious note (“I made it through the wilderness / Somehow I made it through / I didn’t know how lost I was / Until I found you”), Tom’s first inclination was to approach it as a ballad. Then, when he arrived at the chorus, the ballad approach sounded ridiculous. It was out of frustration that Tom started to play the bass line and sing falsetto. As soon as I heard it, I said, “That’s it!”

When he arrived at the chorus, the ballad approach sounded ridiculous.

Billy Steinberg

And so you and Tom recorded a simple, keyboard-based, eight-track demo at his home studio. What technology did you use? Was it you or Tom who sang on the demo?

The demo for “Like a Virgin” was recorded on an 8-track system. It is a simple demo with Tom on synthesizer and lead vocals. I sang a few “atmospheric” backing vocals, including the “hey!” after the title. We used a Linn drum pattern.

Were you both happy with the finished demo? Did you feel that “Like a Virgin” was a very original song, and that it could be a hit?

Tom and I were very happy with the song after we finished it. We knew we had something unique. Musically, it was inspired by Motown, ie: Holland, Dozier & Holland’s “I Can’t Help Myself”, but lyrically it was very cutting edge. We felt the song could be a hit if there wasn’t too much resistance to the bold lyric.

But the success of a song also depends on the artist who records it. Did you have any idea of the right artist for “Like a Virgin” while you were writing it?

Tom and I never tried to write songs with particular artists in mind. So, when we wrote “Like a Virgin” we were just having fun. After the song was completed, we realized it would be difficult to cast. There weren’t many artists in the early eighties who could sing it.

We heard that it took more than a year to find the right artist for “Like a Virgin”, because the title and the theme seemed a bit jolting and risqué. When did you finally find Madonna?

Tom and I had a meeting with Warner Brothers A&R man Michael Ostin. It was a chance for us to play him songs that we had been writing. I don’t think that before the meeting we had put “Like a Virgin” and Madonna together in our minds. I knew of Madonna because my girlfriend at the time was an aerobics instructor and she used Madonna’s “Burning Up”. This meeting occurred before the success of “Borderline” or “Lucky Star”. After playing several other song demos, we played “Like a Virgin”. Michael loved it immediately and suggested it would be right for Madonna.

Have you ever met Madonna?

Tom and I never met Madonna until several years after the song became a hit.

Did you give any input during the recording sessions?

We weren’t involved in her recording process. She was working with producer Nile Rodgers.

Did you have the chance to hear Madonna’s first demo, or did you simply have to wait for the final cut?

Michael Ostin gave us a copy of Madonna’s version after it was finished.

Can you tell us what changes Madonna and Nile introduced?

Madonna’s recording of “Like a Virgin” is almost exactly like our original demo. Madonna copied all of Tom’s vocal inflections and ad libs right to the end of our demo. Nile Rodgers’ main contribution was the live bass and drums. Other than that, she followed the map of our demo.

Madonna’s recording of “Like a Virgin” is almost exactly like our original demo.

Billy Steinberg

After hearing Madonna’s cut, did you realise that “Like a Virgin” was going to be such a masterpiece?

When Tom and I heard Madonna’s recording of “Like a Virgin”, we felt confident that it would be a hit.

Do you think her performance at the first MTV Video Music Awards, before the song had even been released, is one of the reasons it had such a great impact?

She recorded it while Warner Brothers was promoting her first album. They were surprised when “Holiday”, “Borderline” and “Lucky Star” became so popular and received so much airplay. They kept having to push back the release schedule of “Like a Virgin”. For that reason, “Like a Virgin” hadn’t yet been released when Madonna appeared on the MTV Video Music Awards. Her performance took the world by surprise. It was so audacious. At first, Tom and I were worried that it was unflattering of Madonna and would affect the performance of the song. The camera followed her as she rolled around the stage. It only seemed to increase the public’s insatiable interest in her.

Were you honoured that “Like a Virgin” was also chosen as the album title?

I was thrilled that “Like a Virgin” was chosen as the title of the album. Also, “True Colors” was the title of Cyndi Lauper’s second album. I loved the photo they selected for the cover of the Like a Virgin album.

Speaking of Cyndi Lauper: Madonna and Cyndi were compared so many times in the 80s. Do you think Cyndi could have put “Like a Virgin” across quite as Madonna did?

I don’t think that Cyndi Lauper could have delivered “Like a Virgin” as effectively as Madonna did. At the time, Cyndi’s image was more artsy. Madonna’s image was more blatantly sexy. Cyndi’s music had more rock influences. Madonna’s music was more “dance”. “Like a Virgin” was influenced by Motown Soul. It worked better for Madonna. And, crucially, it was a match made in heaven for a girl named “Madonna” to sing a song with the word “virgin” in the title.

What do you think of the video they filmed in Venice, Italy? Do you think it fits the theme of the song?

When I first saw the video for “Like a Virgin”, I thought the Venice, Italy thing was silly. I couldn’t see how it related to the song. Also, the gondola and the lion seemed odd. I wouldn’t say it’s a great video, but it is exotic and it caught people’s attention.

Have you seen the opening scenes of Quentin Tarantino’s Reservoir Dogs, where they talk about Madonna and “Like a Virgin”? They say that “Like a Virgin” “is all about a girl who digs a guy with a big d*ck”, that “the whole song is a metaphor for big d*cks”. It is one more proof that “Like a Virgin” is an anthem, isn’t it?

I thought the Reservoir Dogs scene was funny. I am constantly amazed at how often “Like a Virgin” is referenced.

Did you see how Madonna reinvented “Like a Virgin” on her Blond Ambition and Girlie Show tours? What are your thoughts?

I liked the way Madonna re-invented “Like a Virgin” in her tours. I wish she would re-invent it again! On her last tour, she didn’t perform it.

Twenty years after “Like a Virgin”, Madonna performed with Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera at the MTV Video Music Awards, in an ironic re-creation of her famous performance at the first ceremony. Christina and Britney opened the show singing the song; then Madonna came on stage, dressed as their groom, sang “Hollywood”, and finally kissed them on the mouth. Did you see it?

I loved the Madonna / Christina / Britney thing. It is flattering when a 20-year-old song can remain provocative.

Do you think that Britney, Christina or another of the new pop sensations could deliver the song quite as Madonna did in the 80s, supposing Madonna had never released it?

I don’t think that anyone before, during or after Madonna could have delivered “Like a Virgin” with equal impact. She had the perfect voice and the perfect image.

What would you say to those who think that Madonna is all business and has no talent?

People seriously underrate Madonna’s songwriting talent. She co-writes most of her hits, including wonderful songs like “Like a Prayer”, “Live to Tell” and “Music”. It is my understanding that she writes the lyrics and the melody topline on the songs she co-writes. I think that most of her musical collaborators provide the musical track. She is a great songwriter. This is sadly often overlooked.

I think Madonna is a classic pop singer. Her voice is also underrated. Cyndi Lauper’s voice is more powerful, but Madonna’s is perfect for pop. To compare them as singers is like comparing Diana Ross to Aretha Franklin. Aretha, the more powerful singer, never could have delivered the perfect vocals on all the Holland, Dozier & Holland songs for the Supremes.

People seriously underrate Madonna’s songwriting talent.

Billy Steinberg

Would you like to write a song with her?

I have always wanted to write a song with Madonna. Tom and I tried to make that connection after “Like a Virgin” was a hit, but, apparently, she wasn’t interested. I was jealous when my friend, Rick Nowels, got to write with her.

Let’s talk about “True Colors”. Did you originally write it for Cyndi Lauper?

“True Colors” was not written for Cyndi. In fact, our demo was piano-based and was loosely inspired by songs like “Bridge Over Troubled Water” and “Let It Be”. Where Madonna copied the demo of “Like a Virgin”, Cyndi completely reinvented the song when she recorded it. I think her recording of “True Colors” is brilliant. Tom and I got lucky that Cyndi chose to record it. No other artist at that time could have given it such a creative, poignant reading.

Phil Collins recently covered “True Colors”. Do you like his version?

I was pleased that Phil Collins covered “True Colors”, but I don’t think his version is as effective as Cyndi’s.

Among all the songs you have written, which is your favourite? And which one had the greatest impact?

Tom and I wrote some great songs together. I can’t say I have one favorite. I like different ones for different reasons. “Like a Virgin” and the Divinyls’ “I Touch Myself” had cutting edge impact. “Eternal Flame” is a beautiful melody and reminds me of a Beatles song. “I Drove All Night” is dramatic like a Roy Orbison song. One of the highlights of my life was working with Roy to record his vocals on it. It was just Roy, Tom and me in Tom’s home studio. Writing with Chrissie Hynde was a great honor. I love “I’ll Stand by You”. But, when we first wrote it, I worried that it wasn’t a Pretenders song. It seemed sort of conventional. Of all our songs I think “Like a Virgin” has had the most impact, but “True Colors” is probably the standard.

Can you tell us what you are currently working on?

I am currently writing with an amazing young writer named Josh Alexander. We have been writing together for about 2 years. We have 3 songs coming out by Fefe Dobson, including her first single, “Don’t Let It Go to Your Head”. We also wrote a song for t.A.T.u. which is being considered as the first single for their upcoming CD. The song is called “All About Us”. In addition, we wrote 3 songs for the Veronicas (a new act on Warner Brothers), which will soon be released.

And what are your goals today?

Working with Josh has really given me a new injection of excitement. I feel really keen to write songs again. It’s wonderful. My goal is for us to write some big hits that will have the impact that songs like “Like a Virgin” and “True Colors” have had.